Welcome Guest! To enable all features please Login or Register.

Notification

Icon
Error

Login


overall thoughts
Tony Raven
#1 Posted : Wednesday, January 06, 2010 6:12:08 PM(UTC)
Rank: Guitar God
Tony Raven
Groups: Registered

Joined: 12/5/2009(UTC)
Posts: 1,312
Points: 3,960
Location: Northern Tier, EEUU
I'm really enjoying my sporadic digs through the issues. Some random thoughts before I stagger off to bed.

(1) Can you reduce the "splash" page behind the articles? I'm an old newspaper guy, & that "above the fold" area is PRIME real estate. The head, subhead, byline, & first few lines should show up in most browsers in order to get reader commitment.

(2) Loving the "tube vs. transistor" stuff. As much as I have stood in awe at the rise of simulators, I still have two non-chip solid-state amps I'm reluctant to part with, so I guess it's a three-way fight. As someone who's humped big tube amps up steep fire escapes (not to mention plywood JBL "Voice of the Theater" behemoths), I'm big on diffuse PA & small amps fed to the board. Tube components can be wonderful, but the fact is that glass tubes break at the damndest times. And, sadly, most of the audience even in the 1980s couldn't tell heavenly overdrive from Radio Shack fuzzbox, & some wouldn't have the first clue if everyone on stage was out of tune -- they're there for the show. Now that they're raised on mp3, why should we drag a $3,500 studio-quality stack up those damned steps?

(3) A few more long, in-depth articles would be great.

(4) How about more tutorials? Sure, there's great stuff to be had on the Web, but why not have your site more as destination? Your audience is growing, so there's (hopefully) going to be new readers showing up all the time. How to set up your guitar. The best order to put the most common stompboxes in. How to shop for a good used guitar or amp. Variant tunings. Slide basics. Why stuff like fingerboard radius & neck shape matter. Overview of pickup types, working toward some of the cool variants. What the heck an "ohm" is & why it matters.

And, with that, I'm off to wind down the first workweek of 2010....
Sponsor
Will Chen
#2 Posted : Thursday, January 07, 2010 2:52:41 AM(UTC)

Rank: Administration
Will Chen
Medals:
Groups: Administrators

Joined: 8/4/2009(UTC)
Posts: 1,937
Points: 5,566
Location: Allen, TX
Thanks so much for the feedback!

I had super big plans for FG when it first started and was ramping up though 2009 peaking about mid year. Since then funding has been an issue as while the advertising covers the raw hosting expenses, it has been an uphill battle to get enough gear to review on a consistent basis. Of course diversifying would be a great way to generate content without having to consistently put up funds. On the other hand, in December we had the most visitors we've ever had and I only put up 2 reviews from Jeff. Here are some direct comments:

(1) Can you reduce the "splash" page behind the articles? I'm an old newspaper guy, & that "above the fold" area is PRIME real estate. The head, subhead, byline, & first few lines should show up in most browsers in order to get reader commitment.

I've gone back and forth regarding the design from trying to make it feel more like a magazine to doing something artistic. Likely another redesign is in store for 2010 to try and present the content in a more indexed fashion making it easier for visitors to find what their looking for.

(2) Loving the "tube vs. transistor" stuff...

Thanks man. That was probably the most research I've done for an article on FG.

(3) A few more long, in-depth articles would be great.

I hope to have many more. However, these take a fairly long time to write due to the amount of research necessary. I really want to do one on the effects of construction and materials on tone including some opinions from luthiers (who hopefully have some contradictory opinions).

(4) How about more tutorials?

I hope to! I hope to expand the mod section to include some more detailed articles.

Check out my music: http://willchentrio.com | http://www.reverbnation.com/willchentrio
Tony Raven
#3 Posted : Thursday, January 07, 2010 2:50:41 PM(UTC)
Rank: Guitar God
Tony Raven
Groups: Registered

Joined: 12/5/2009(UTC)
Posts: 1,312
Points: 3,960
Location: Northern Tier, EEUU
You could always reach out to The Guild of American Luthiers: http://www.luth.org/index.html

At first blush, that may look the exact wrong thing! After all, a big chunk of their membership is people trying to make a living from lovingly-constructed four- & five-figure instruments. But, trust me, there's a madness to my method. Cool Admit to them that (in your opinion) there are millyuns & millyuns of people who think they want to play guitar, so they go & plunk down cash for whatever looks cool, has the right number of strings, & the sales clerk is trying to dump. And often, it's questionably made or poorly set up or both, but the poor schmoes are made to feel it's their fault for not being dedicated enough, so they put the axe out at the garage sale & never try again.

You want to fix that. The GAL wants to fix that. And if people like you can get more people savvy about what's really going on, then that'll increase the pool of dedicated guitarists who'll work their way up to really excellent high-end guitars. In other words, everyone who loves guitars is all on the same page.

You want to put out good information for the masses, selling nothing beyond a successful magazine. And you'd like to give experts a chance to strut their stuff.

Have a trudge through their "Links & Resources" pages, particularly Instrument Makers: http://www.luth.org/links/makers.htm. When you contact these individual shops, offer to publish an article, & mention some specific questions that're on your mind that they might enjoy answering. Some of the Luthiery Schools listed might be interested in showing off what students have done, especially if they get a clickable mention.

Anyhow, let it percolate. The good stuff will occur to you.
Cirrus
#4 Posted : Monday, May 31, 2010 1:47:26 AM(UTC)
Rank: Shredder
Cirrus
Groups: Registered

Joined: 1/6/2010(UTC)
Posts: 134
Points: 405
Location: Kansas City
Personally, I would like to see a lot more "frugal" guitar reviews. Surely you could reach out to some companies, let them know what FG is all about, and let you review a of their models.

There seem to be a lot of competitive models coming out of the Asian market and sometimes people, myself included, are afraid to try new things because of a lack on information on these new models.

I think you would get a lot more traffic at the sight.

Just my .02...
Will Chen
#5 Posted : Tuesday, June 01, 2010 2:45:59 AM(UTC)

Rank: Administration
Will Chen
Medals:
Groups: Administrators

Joined: 8/4/2009(UTC)
Posts: 1,937
Points: 5,566
Location: Allen, TX
Cirrus wrote:
Personally, I would like to see a lot more "frugal" guitar reviews. Surely you could reach out to some companies, let them know what FG is all about, and let you review a of their models.

There seem to be a lot of competitive models coming out of the Asian market and sometimes people, myself included, are afraid to try new things because of a lack on information on these new models.

I think you would get a lot more traffic at the sight.

Just my .02...


Well...it's a balancing act. The question I have is if 20 small companies are selling strat and tele clones, there's maybe a handful of actual manufacturers behind them. As such I'm really only reviewing a handful of instruments over and over again with the only difference being the headstock logo...which is why I'm trying to focus on more unique instruments or companies which have control over their production process.

Regarding reviewing some of these lesser known models, I'm doing my best. But the reality is they don't generate many more visitors as the companies behind them don't effectively market their product so there is very little knowledge that they actually exist, and therefore not very much interest in them or reviews about them.

All that being said, got a review of the redesigned Arbor AS310 coming up real soon...
Check out my music: http://willchentrio.com | http://www.reverbnation.com/willchentrio
Tony Raven
#6 Posted : Tuesday, June 01, 2010 3:32:27 PM(UTC)
Rank: Guitar God
Tony Raven
Groups: Registered

Joined: 12/5/2009(UTC)
Posts: 1,312
Points: 3,960
Location: Northern Tier, EEUU
Obviously, I'm just gonna have to win the Powerball, & then I'll order a hundred $250 axes & send 'em to Will. Cool

Barring that, each & every member of FG.com can help out: review your "off brand" gear here. Put the brand & model name/number & the word "Review" in the title. (I keep forgetting that last one -- sorry, Will & all.)

Really -- it's that simple.

If you Google for AXL Badwater, Will's review of the Eldorado SE in FrugalGuitarist.com pops up near the top of Page 2, which indicates that people have found the review & linked into it. That's edging into the territory of HUGE sites.

You don't need to do serious teardown stuff. Just your impressions as a player, the features you like, the rough edges you notice, how it sounds plugged & unplugged, the amount of tweaking you need to do out-of-box, & like that. Even reviews of used & classic gear will chivvy traffic up a tiny bit.
Cirrus
#7 Posted : Friday, June 04, 2010 3:31:40 AM(UTC)
Rank: Shredder
Cirrus
Groups: Registered

Joined: 1/6/2010(UTC)
Posts: 134
Points: 405
Location: Kansas City
Quote:
Well...it's a balancing act. The question I have is if 20 small companies are selling strat and tele clones, there's maybe a handful of actual manufacturers behind them. As such I'm really only reviewing a handful of instruments over and over again with the only difference being the headstock logo...which is why I'm trying to focus on more unique instruments or companies which have control over their production process.


I understand that. But maybe if you do something like than then you can list names of other guitars made by the same manufacturer. Then we would assume that product with be very similar to the models you listed. For those of us like myself, we know there are all kinds of different companies making copies, but we don't know which ones are made by the same manufacturers.
Users browsing this topic
Guest
Forum Jump  
You cannot post new topics in this forum.
You cannot reply to topics in this forum.
You cannot delete your posts in this forum.
You cannot edit your posts in this forum.
You cannot create polls in this forum.
You cannot vote in polls in this forum.